One
significant aspect of any kitchen remodel is what is the countertop going to
be? Two popular choices are Granite and
CaesarStone. So what are the
differences? What are the pros and cons?
We’ve done countless jobs with both materials and would like to give you
a little insight into the two products.
Material
Granite is obviously a solid
slab of stone. There are countless
varieties of granite. Granite differs
mostly on where it comes from, chemical makeup, colors, density, porosity,
amount of pitting, etc.
CaesarStone is a
manufactured product using 93% quartz aggregates and 7% pigments and resin
(which bonds the stone together).
Color
Granite comes in countless
colors and variations (check out http://www.tropicalstone.com/
for a glimpse of the many choices).
Since it is a natural stone, no two are alike. Each slab of granite, even if it is the same
kind/name, can look completely different than the next slab.
CaesarStone currently
offers 40 variations (http://caesarstoneus.com).
The quartz is completely natural, but because it is smaller pieces, with
pigments added, and the final product manufactured in a factory, the same color/variation
is going to look the same everywhere you see it.
Staining
Granite- Although many people
don’t realize it, granite is porous and susceptible to staining. Lighter variations are more vulnerable to
staining than darker colors because it is more porous. Granite needs to be resealed once a year
minimum to help reduce the likelihood of getting stained and prevent it from
getting a dull appearance. You also have
to watch what cleaner you use on granite because some can counteract the sealer
and damage the stone.
CaesarStone is
approximately 17 times less porous than Granite and thus virtually stain
resistant. There is no need to ever seal
CaesarStone and there is no annual maintenance. You can also use any product to wipe the
surface.
Durability
This
category is going to be a direct comparison.
CaesarStone is much more
crack and break resistant than granite, as it performs over two times better in
sudden impact tests and almost four times better in flexural (slow, constant
pressure) tests. Both materials are highly scratch resistant.
Warranty
Granite- Warranties for granite
are really going to depend on the supplier of the stone and the fabricator of
the stone. The majority of the places
will offer no warranty on the actual piece of granite itself because it is a
natural stone and they cannot guarantee it will be free of defects. Most fabricators will offer a one year
warranty on the installation though.
CaesarStone offers
a lifetime warranty on its product and installation. The warranty is for residences only and indoor use; they
have a different warranty for commercial properties. It also must be installed by a CaesarStone Certified
Fabricator, which there is an abundance of.
Price
Granite
can range as low as $50
per square foot installed to $150+ easily depending on the variation.
Not all granite is equal. As mentioned before there are many
variations
affecting the quality of granite. Low
end often has pits in the surface. Some
granite is priced low because that type is so readily available and
often the
lower end can be more porous and susceptible to stains. The biggest
thing is ensuring you have a
quality fabricator and installer. Last
thing you want is to spend several thousand dollars for a good stone
and have
the installer permanently mess it up.
CaesarStone
typically ranges from $60-98 per square foot installed. The cost difference solely depends on the
color/variation you pick. All of
CaesarStone is of the same quality with lifetime warranty. With a CaesarStone Certified Fabricator, you
are sure to have a good installation since it will be under the company’s
warranty.
Final
Choice
Of
course the final decision is always up to the homeowner. I hope this entry helped shine a little light
on the subject and will help you make your decision. Both are good choices and it ultimately comes
down to your preferences and what works best for you and your lifestyle. We consistently use both in our kitchen renovations
(as well as bath vanities and custom built-ins). Thinking about remodeling? Rissay can always help with both the design
and construction of your project. Feel
free to e-mail us at [email protected] or
call 215-713-0750.